What if You have Unclean Hands in a Qui Tam Lawsuit?

amaury-salas-IhXrWDckZOQ-unsplash-copy-300x194Many times, an employee has identified fraud against the government occurring within their place of employment. They want to report this fraud, or blow the whistle, but are afraid to because they participated in the fraud. This is often an extremely difficult situation. Potential whistleblowers know the fraud is wrong, but they also do not want to face repercussions for it. However, their involvement was likely entirely forced by their employer. The employee may want to blow the whistle to stop their own involvement, or they may just want to do the right thing. 

When someone is involved with defrauding the government, they are considered to have unclean hands. If an employer forced the employee to participate in the fraud, they may be immune from being found with unclean hands.

The Department of Justice and Unclean Hands

Truthfully speaking, the Department of Justice rarely prosecutes those who participated in fraud, but also blew the whistle on that same fraud. This is because the vast majority of money recovered by the government in fraud lawsuits comes from whistleblowers. The Department of Justice does not want to deter whistleblowers from coming forward and as such, they will rarely press charges against whistleblowers. 

The Federal False Claims Act

The federal False Claims Act does protect whistleblowers against retaliation from their employer if they inform the government of fraudulent activities. However, there are no specific provisions that protect whistleblowers from facing prosecution if they participated in the fraud. 

Still, the Department of Justice recognizes that employees are often coerced into engaging in fraudulent behavior. When they do so, they are scared for their jobs and income, knowing there is a real threat of losing them if they do not help with the fraud. Secondly, the Department of Justice wants whistleblowers to continue coming forward. If they are prosecuted, it is a deterrent to anyone who wants to come forward in the future. 

The California False Claims Act

Unfortunately for whistleblowers in California, there is a provision in the California False Claims Act that allows those that have engaged in fraud to face prosecution, even if they blew the whistle on their employer. This is stated under Cal. Gov Code section 12652(g)(5), which states the plaintiff in a qui tam lawsuit can have his or her award reduced below the normal 15% minimum if that person has engaged in fraud. 

However, this provision only applies to whistleblowers who planned and initiated the fraud. As such, those individuals that are pressured or coerced by their employers to participate in the fraud are still free from prosecution, as long as they did not plan or initiate the criminal activity. 

Need to File a Whistleblower Lawsuit? Call a California Qui Tam Lawyer

If you have witnessed fraudulent activity at your workplace, do not try to blow the whistle on your own. A qui tam lawyer in California can ensure that your rights are upheld and that you get the full award to which you are entitled. At Willoughy Brod, LLP, we are passionate about stopping fraud against the government, and want to help whistleblowers get the full compensation. If you need help, call us today at (800) 427-7020 or fill out our online form. We offer free consultations so we will review your case at no charge and advise you of all your legal options. 


Related Posts:

Collecting Evidence in a Qui Tam Lawsuit

What to Do if Your Employer Retaliates After You Blow the Whistle

(image courtesy of Amaury Salas)

Justia Lawyer Rating for Gregory J. Brod
Contact Information